Why is getting a new one out of the question? I know they are not commonly available but they do seem to be around, and it appears that Tim has a rebuilt one.
Is there something wrong with it? Or did it just separate? I have seen that happen many times and most of the time have been able to drill a hole in the cast piece that then allows me to use a zip tie to hold the plastic section on the cast part. I know I did that to my 73 about 15 years ago after getting a 'fix' ticket from a cop for having my reverse lights on. I seem to recall that even 15 years ago the one for my 73 was hard to find, a few years earlier and later no problem but of course mine was an odd one. Its worked great ever since. From time to time I have run into it with other cars too and they were all pretty similar.